Unexpectedly Intriguing!
March 9, 2020

As expected, the S&P 500 (Index: SPX) continues to experience an impressive amount of volatility on a day-to-day basis.

Since we've been appending updated bits of analysis to our previous S&P 500 chaos posting during each day of the past week, we're going to focus this new edition on what happened on Friday, 6 March 2020, after we animate all the moves that took place since the close of trading on Friday, 28 February 2020 and quickly summarize the week that was. If you're accessing this article on a site that republishes our RSS news feed, please click through to our site to access the animation:

Animation: Alternative Futures - S&P 500 - 2020Q1 - Standard Model - Snapshots from 28 Feb 2020 through 6 Mar 2020

Each of the large swings in stock prices during the previous week coincided with major swings in how far into the future investors were focusing their attention, as changing expectations for the size and timing of interest rate cuts by the U.S. Federal Reserve led investors to alter their forward-looking focus back and forth between 2020-Q2 and 2020-Q4 from Friday, 28 February 2020 through Thursday, 5 March 2020. The following animated image captures those changes during the week ending on Friday, 6 March 2020, where the thing we want to point out is how little changed those expectations were between Thursday, 5 March 2020 and Friday, 6 March 2020.

Animation: CME Group FedWatch Tool Probabilities of Federal Funds Rate Changing at Future FOMC Meeting Dates, Snapshots from 28 February 2020 through 06 March 2020

On Friday, 6 March 2020, the dividend futures-based model indicated that investors shifted their attention more toward 2020-Q2, but unlike the previous days in the week, that change was unaccompanied by a change in the probabilities of the size and timing of how the Fed will change the Federal Funds Rate.

The big thing that changed on Friday, 6 March 2020 were the expectations for future dividends, which saw declines in the amount of cash dividends projected to be paid in upcoming future quarters from 2020-Q2 through 2020-Q4. In the following chart, we've animated the daily closing values indicated by the CME Group's futures for S&P 500 quarterly dividends for the future quarters of 2020-Q1 (which may still be in some flux until the dividend futures contracts for the quarter expire on the third Friday of March) through 2020-Q4, for each trading day from Friday, 28 February 2020 through Friday, 6 March 2020.

Animation: Past and Projected Quarterly Dividends Per Share Futures for S&P 500, 2019-Q1 Through 2020-Q4, Snapshots 28 February 2020 through 6 March 2020

From Friday, 28 February 2020 through Thursday, 5 March 2020, the day-to-day changes in the S&P 500's expected future quarterly dividends is largely consistent with day-to-day noise in these futures. On Friday, 6 March 2020, we see significant decreases in the amount of dividends expected to be paid out in the future quarters of 2020-Q2 through 2020-Q4, which adds a new, downward force to affect stock prices.

This so far speculative change will work to concentrate investor focus on 2020-Q2, since this will be the period in which companies affected by the developing global economic situation resulting from China's coronavirus breakout will begin announcing changes in their business outlooks and their future dividend payouts.

Regardless, the S&P 500 has now entered into a new phase of its current period of volatility, where changes in expected future dividends, the fundamental driver of stock prices, will affect changes in stock prices.

Speaking of which, here is a more comprehensive listing of the past week's market-moving headlines than what we've previously presented in our daily appendices:

Monday, 2 March 2020
Tuesday, 3 March 2020
Wednesday, 4 March 2020
Thursday, 5 March 2020
Friday, 6 March 2020

Barry Ritholtz listed the positives and negatives he found in the past week's economics and market-related news.

As the market's volatility remains elevated, we'll append daily updates to the original version of this article. Meanwhile, previous posts in our S&P 500 chaos series are also available.

Venturing Into Bear Territory...

Update 9 March 2020 at 9:05 PM Eastern: There's nothing quite like throwing oil onto a market fire, is there? Here is the biggest market moving headline for the day:

The effect on stock prices was drastic, with the S&P 500 dropping 7.60% for the largest single day decline since Thursday, 9 October 2008, when stock prices dove by 7.62% in the midst of the global financial crisis, though the large drop on this day was precipitated by new the bottom was set to fall out from the automotive industry.

Flash forward to 2020, the global automotive industry is again on the rocks, but the collapse in oil prices as Saudi Arabia, upset that Russia wouldn't go along with cutting oil output, reacted by initiating a price war, promising to sharply increase its production and sending global oil prices sharply lower.

That affects the outlook for the S&P 500 because U.S. oil producers have become exporters to the global market, where the decline in oil prices will negatively impact their bottom lines. So much so that the S&P 500's quarterly dividends per share projected for both 2020-Q3 and 2020-Q4 plunged on the day's news.

We've updated the three charts we presented in the original article. Please click on the following individual images to access larger versions of the charts.

Alternative Futures - S&P 500 - 2020Q1 - Standard Model - Snapshot on 9 March 2020
CME Group FedWatch Tool: Probabilities of Federal Funds Rate Changes at Upcoming FOMC Meetings, Snapshot 9 March 2020

It looks like the S&P 500 has overshot the typical range of values the dividend futures-based model anticipates the S&P 500 would be with investors closely focused on 2020-Q2 in setting current day stock prices. That could be good in that it suggests the market may be predisposed to rebound a bit, but that hinges in good part on the random onset of new information, which may give investors other ideas.

Meanwhile, investors appear to be baking in at least a three quarter point rate cut by the U.S. Federal Reserve, though they are giving elevated odds of the Fed cutting rates to near zero at the Federal Open Market Committee's next meeting in less than two weeks.

On a final note, the S&P 500 has only seen six larger daily percentage declines since January 1950 than it did on Monday, 9 March 2020. The largest two date back to October 1987, and the remaining four are linked to different points of the global financial crisis and other formative events for the Great Recession that took place just before or during the last quarter of 2008.

S&P 500 Completes Second Lévy Flight Event of 2020

Update 10 March 2020: The S&P 500 rebounded today, though not without significant noise related to whether the U.S. Congress would come forward with fiscal stimulus. Although the market started out up by 7% in pre-trading, nearly all that gain was loss when news broke that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi indicated her party wouldn't be ready to meet on a fiscal plan this week, but recovered somewhat when Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin communicated there was "bipartisan urgency" for such a package later in the day.

See what we meant when we said that a rebound in stock prices today "hinges in good part on the random onset of new information"?

Ultimately, the S&P 500 rebounded back up to the level the dividend futures-based model indicates it would be if investors were closely focused on 2020-Q2 in setting current day stock prices. In doing so, the S&P 500 completed the second Lévy flight event of 2020, with investors have transferred their attention from the distant future quarter of 2020-Q4 to the much nearer term future of 2020-Q2.

Since there wasn't much change in the expectations for future S&P 500 quarter dividends, we'll present the alternative futures chart showing the latest update to the actual trajectory of the S&P 500 and the latest update to the CME Group's FedWatch Tool's indicated probabilities for future changes in the Federal Funds Rate. Please click on the individual images to access larger versions of these charts.

Alternative Futures - S&P 500 - 2020Q1 - Standard Model - Snapshot on 9 March 2020
CME Group FedWatch Tool: Probabilities of Federal Funds Rate Changes at Upcoming FOMC Meetings, Snapshot 9 March 2020

Now that it has arrived here, will the market's volatility settle down somewhat and stabilize? Stay tuned!...

Descending Into A True Bear Market...

Update 11 March 2020: The flow of news is such that the market doesn't look like it will be likely to stabilize anytime soon, and that's before bigger, badder news broke after the market closed:

Here are the latest updates to the three charts we've featured above. Please click on the following individual images to access larger versions of the charts.

Alternative Futures - S&P 500 - 2020Q1 - Standard Model - Snapshot on 11 March 2020
CME Group FedWatch Tool: Probabilities of Federal Funds Rate Changes at Upcoming FOMC Meetings, Snapshot 11 March 2020

Aside from the drop in the level of the S&P 500, which we'll get to in just a moment, investors are now expecting the Fed to slash the Federal Funds Rate to the zero bound range when they meet next week, and expectations for future dividends dipped through 2020-Q4, and although it's not shown in the chart, they dropped significantly for 2021-Q1.

Looking at what the dividend futures model is communicating for the future of the S&P 500, we are at the point where the future for stock prices is locking in at a much lower level, which you can see in the lower right hand corner of the alternative futures chart. That lower level has been forming since the S&P 500's second Lévy flight event began, and with the flight now complete, what is to stop stock prices from proceeding to that now defined lower level sooner rather than waiting a week before going there later as the standard dividend futures-based model suggests?

That thought has been in the back of our minds since yesterday's update. We could add one of our redzone-style forecast ranges to show that transition on the chart, but given the heightened volatility, it would make for a rather large block to show on the chart in a relatively small space, so it wouldn't provide much benefit in visually communicating the scenario we described. The best case scenario would be for investors to find a reason to shift their forward looking focus to either 2020-Q3 or 2020-Q4, but at this point, that would mean stock prices moving sideways, and it is unclear what kind of new information could achieve that effect at this time.

We alluded to it at the beginning of this update, but the World Health Organization's declaration that the coronavirus epidemic that originated in China has become a global pandemic, combined with news indicating its rapid spread that came out after the market closed, may mean we'll see the scenario we just described play out as early as tomorrow. We'll find out soon enough.

The Bottom Keeps Dropping

Update 12 March 2020: As expected, rather than waiting, the S&P 500 dropped to the lower level the dividend-futures model was signaling they would if investors remained closely focused on 2020-Q2 sooner. We finally hit on the idea of using a simple red arrow in the alternative futures chart below to show that correspondence and the S&P 500's earlier arrival at this level than the model had projected several weeks ago. At the same time, expectations for the S&P 500's future dividend payouts in 2020-Q2, 2020-Q3, and 2020-Q4 were also walloped on the day, which we've shown in the second chart.

Alternative Futures - S&P 500 - 2020Q1 - Standard Model - Snapshot on 12 March 2020
Past and Projected Quarterly Dividends Futures for the S&P 500, 2019-Q1 through 2020-Q4, Snapshot on 9 March 2020

We're omitting the day's update for the chart of the CME Group's FedWatch Tool's probabilities of Federal Funds Rate changes since it really didn't change from Wednesday, 11 March 2020. We're thinking there may not be much more to see there until they adapt it to accommodate negative interest rates.

Speaking of the Fed, they launched a $1.5 trillion bazooka in looking to flood the repo market with liquidity, only to find out that wasn't the kind of liquidity the market was looking for. At the same time, they also removed any remaining difference between the quantitative easing-like program they have been operating and the kind of QE the market came to know during the Obama administration.

All that wasn't enough, and to be fair, that may have a lot to do with the sheer monetary and fiscal policy fecklessness that's going on in Europe. Now is one of those times when coordinated actions by central banks were needed, and the ECB chose to keep standing on the sidelines, tanking global stock prices as a result.

Want to know what scares us? Look at the bottom right corner of the alternative futures chart. That future hasn't yet been fixed, but if today's change in dividend futures holds, we may once again find the S&P 500 looking to drop faster than even the dividend futures model can handle.

And that's saying something, since we developed the key insight behind it in late 2008 and early 2009 when the S&P 500 was experiencing a similarly cratering market!

In any case, we're going to change gears tomorrow to take a needed break from the daily coronavirus-caused market carnage, then we'll be back on Monday in our regular S&P 500 chaos series posting to wrap up the week.

Labels: , ,

About Political Calculations

Welcome to the blogosphere's toolchest! Here, unlike other blogs dedicated to analyzing current events, we create easy-to-use, simple tools to do the math related to them so you can get in on the action too! If you would like to learn more about these tools, or if you would like to contribute ideas to develop for this blog, please e-mail us at:

ironman at politicalcalculations.com

Thanks in advance!

Recent Posts

Stock Charts and News

Most Popular Posts
Quick Index

Site Data

This site is primarily powered by:

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

CSS Validation

Valid CSS!

RSS Site Feed

AddThis Feed Button


The tools on this site are built using JavaScript. If you would like to learn more, one of the best free resources on the web is available at W3Schools.com.

Other Cool Resources

Blog Roll

Market Links

Useful Election Data
Charities We Support
Shopping Guides
Recommended Reading
Recently Shopped

Seeking Alpha Certified

Legal Disclaimer

Materials on this website are published by Political Calculations to provide visitors with free information and insights regarding the incentives created by the laws and policies described. However, this website is not designed for the purpose of providing legal, medical or financial advice to individuals. Visitors should not rely upon information on this website as a substitute for personal legal, medical or financial advice. While we make every effort to provide accurate website information, laws can change and inaccuracies happen despite our best efforts. If you have an individual problem, you should seek advice from a licensed professional in your state, i.e., by a competent authority with specialized knowledge who can apply it to the particular circumstances of your case.